Great idea
Ko Black diers get worse service from wait staff and bartenders as white parties is more likely because of racial bias than because of a well-documented fact that tips are less, according to a a new survey I recently posted.
To come to this conclusion, my colleague Gerald Nowak and I hired more than 700 mostly white servers and bartenders in full-service restaurants to review a hypothetical dining room scenario that randomly involved white or black customers. We then asked them to predict the tip the table would leave, the likelihood that the table would exhibit unwanted eating behavior, and the quality of service they would likely provide to the table.
Participants were also asked to complete a survey to find out how often they observed anti-Black expressions of bias in their jobs and find out if they were hiding own prejudices against African Americans.
Servers who either had prejudices against African Americans worked in a restaurant where racist remarks were often heard, or both were much more likely to anticipate that a table with black customers would not only favor them less, but also show a rude, demanding and dishonest behavior. As a result, these servers also reported that they would offer a black table worse than a white one.
We found no evidence of racially different treatment unless one of these two conditions was present: server prejudice or racist words and workplace behavior.
Why it matters
The link between bias and actual discrimination is widely assumed, but rarely documented – be responsible for the mistreatment of black Americans while engaging in a number of routine activities.
In addition to providing new evidence for this link, our results also have important practical implications. Because research shows they are black buyers less known as whites with a tip rate of 15-20%, they usually give less tips. That’s how servers are supposed to be economically motivated provide priority services to white customers who they believe are more likely to reward their efforts.
In response, some suggested to abolish the voluntary tip or to take measures to eliminate the difference between tips between black and white increase knowledge of black parties with tips norms.
However, we found no evidence of stereotypes and discrimination of services in the absence of bias against blacks, suggesting that the solution to this problem lies in addressing racial prejudice in the hospitality industry.
What is not yet known
The disadvantage of our study is that we asked servers how they would think and behave in hypothetical, controlled, and experimentally manipulated conditions. We can’t know for sure how this process would unfold when servers are waiting for actual white and black clients. That would be very challenging. And because our participants were not randomly selected, our ability to know how well they reflect the views and jobs of all the servers and bartenders across the country is limited.
Nevertheless preliminary research has documented the relationship between what people say they would do under hypothetical conditions and what they actually do when faced with similar situations, giving us some confidence in the real use of our results.
What’s next
We are currently examining racial discrimination on the other side of the table by examining the tendency of restaurant customers to discriminate against black servers by giving them less tips than whites. By conducting a survey experiment for more than 2,000 restaurant guests across the country, our ongoing research project aims to further document this form of consumer racial discrimination.
[Deep knowledge, daily. Sign up for The Conversation’s newsletter.]
This article is republished from Talk, a non-profit news site dedicated to exchanging ideas from academic experts. He wrote: Zachary Brewster,, Wayne State University.
Read more:
Zachary Brewster does not work for, consult with, hold any interest in any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have not disclosed any significant connection other than their academic appointment.